Wrongful Discharge

At-will's Big Exception

Under the employment at-will doctrine, an employer can discharge employees for any reason, even bad reasons, except for unlawful reasons.   Wrongful discharges are those exceptions. When terminations violate the rights of employees, they are wrongful. 

Why Wrongful Discharge Matters

When Discharges go Wrong

Courts can remedy the harm caused by a discharge if the employee proves the dishcarge violated his or her rights. Remedies can include payment for lost wages and benefits, as well as for emotional pain and suffering. But if employees cannot prove that their discharge violated their rights, courts have no power to remedy the harm.  

Discharges that Violate Employee Rights

Discharges can violate the rights of employees if they:

  • are motivated  by unlawful reasons, like discrimination or retaliation;
  • violate a contractual right of the employee; or
  • jeopardize established public policies. 

A discharges jeopardizes established public policy of a state when, for example, the state has a policy requiring citizens to serve on a jury when called, and an employer fires an employee for missing work due to jury service.  

MEL discusses unlawful discharges in greater detail under the topics of Contracts, Discrimination, FMLA, HarassmentRetaliation and Public Policy Discharges

Discharges can be Wrong but not Unlawful

If the word "wrong" means the opposite of "right," then some wrong discharges, even though wrong, do not violate employees' rights. For example, until 1964, it was wrong, but not unlawful, for employers in most states to discriminate against employees based on faith, gender or race. Even now it is wrong, but arguably not unlawful, for private employers to discriminate on such grounds in the state of Ohio, as long as they have three or fewer employeesSee Leininger v. Pioneer Nat'l Latex, 115 Ohio St. 3d 311 (Ohio 2007), discussed here

The difference between Wrongful Discharge and Constructive Discharges

Legally speaking, a wrongful discharge is a discharge that violates the rights of an employee. This implies that an employer made the decision to discharge the employee.

Constructive discharge describes a decision made by an employee to quit or resign from employment. A freely made, voluntary quit is usually not a wrongful discharge because it is not a discharge.  The employee resigned. However, the law can treat an otherwise voluntary quit as a discharge if the employer created working conditions so intolerable that a reasonable employee would feel compelled to quit under those circumstances, especially if the employer intended for the employee to quit. The legal significance of a consturctive discharge, then, is that the separation from employment is treated a discharge by the court, and not a voluntary quit. 

Employer actions that can result in constructive disharges may include cut hours, transfers to undesirable shifts or locations or a campaign of harassment aimed at getting the employee to resign. 

Once an employee proves a constructive discharge, it is still just a discharge. Like any other wrongful discharge, employees who were forced to quit must still prove that their employer violated their rights by forcing them to quit.

Related Articles from around the web (89)

Florida wrongful discharge law

Wrongful Discharge in Kentucky: Pleading the Claim

Court of Appeal Expands Wrongful Discharge Law

Wrongful Discharge: Being Fired for Refusing to Violate the Law

Wrongful Discharge - Terminations that Violate Public Policy

Wrongful Discharge for Complaining to an Employer or OSHA about Unsafe Work

"Public Policy" Wrongful Discharge Claim Based on Court Testimony

Ohio Supreme Court clears up “clarity” element of wrongful discharge tort

Kentucky Supreme Court Clarifies "Preemption" of Wrongful Discharge Claims

Does A Wrongful Discharge Under Kentucky Law Require Proof That The Employee Was Ordered To Violate the Law?

"Public Policy" Wrongful Discharge Claim Based on Court Testimony

Wrongful Termination and You

Goodbye Wrongful Demotion?

Do you know? Wrongful terminations for attorney consultations

Wrongful Termination North of the Border

Do you know? Wrongful terminations for attorney consultations

Do you know? Wrongful terminations for attorney consultations

Danville Settles Wrongful Demotion Case

Wrongful Termination is a Narrow Path in the Thickets

What Is A Constructive Discharge?

Limitations on Wrongful Termination Claims by Undocumented Workers

Did Religious Discrimination Lead to Wrongful Termination at NASA?

Wrongful Termination of Firefighter a Result of Gender Discrimination

Is Murder "Good Cause" for Discharge?

What Is A Constructive Discharge In Illinois?

What Is A Constructive Discharge In Illinois?

What Is A Constructive Discharge In Chicago?

What Is A Constructive Discharge In Chicago?

What Is A Constructive Discharge In Chicago?

Constructive Discharge In Chicago

What Is A Constructive Discharge In Chicago?

"Desperate Housewife" Claims Wrongful Termination in Los Angeles

Kentucky Police Chief Pursuing Wrongful Termination Lawsuit

Wrongful Termination Suit Filed against JCPS in Louisville Kentucky

California Court of Appeal Extends Wrongful Termination Cause of Action

TENNESSEE JURY RETURNS $1.5 MILLION AWARD FOR WRONGFUL TERMINATION

When Is Quitting A Constructive Discharge In Chicago

When Is Quitting A Constructive Discharge In Chicago

Overview of the Constructive Discharge Doctrine

Chicago Constructive Discharge Cases

Chicago Constructive Discharge Lawsuits

Discharge Over Facebook Posting Lawful

Chicago Constructive Discharge Cases

Can Protective Orders Lead to Indiana Job Discrimination and Wrongful Termination?

Fired Hurricane Katrina Schoolteachers Win Wrongful Termination Suit

Court of Appeal: Wrongful Termination Alone Insufficient for Punitive Damages Liability

Williams v. Plum Creek Timber Co. Challenges Wrongful Termination in Irvine

Chicago Constructive Discharge Case Information

Chicago Constructive Discharge Cases On The Rise

Eighth Circuit Upholds Professor’s Discharge

Right to Vote without Employer Interference or Threat of Discharge

In Chicago What Is The Difference Between Constructive Discharge and Retaliation

New Decision Examines the Scope of Constructive Discharge

Springfield Illinois Constructive Discharge Cases

When Can You Quit A Job And Call It A Constructive Discharge?

When Can You Quit A Job And Call It A Constructive Discharge?

After-Acquired Evidence Rule Inapplicable to Post-Wrongful Termination Alleged Misconduct

Kentucky Coach Claims Age and Race Discrimination in Wrongful Termination Lawsuit

Las Vegas Hardrock's Owners Sued for Wrongful Death of Ex-CEO's Girlfriend

When Is Sexual Harassment Considered A Constructive Discharge In Chicago?

Court of Appeal: Discharge of Executive Uncooperative in Investigation

Trumped-Up Reasons For Termination Can Prove Retaliatory Discharge

Law Prof Sues Buffalo Dean for Discharge

POINTING A GUN AT MANAGEMENT LEGITIMATE GROUNDS FOR DISCHARGE

Court of Appeal: Reporting Time Pay and Discharge

Threats caused by a bipolar disability are grounds for discharge

Demotion Without Job Description Considered Constructive Discharge

Family and Care Giver Discrimination, Harassment and Discharge

Demotion Without Job Description Considered Constructive Discharge

Lori Adelson contributes to article on reinstating employees after filing wrongful-termination claims

California Plant Worker Sues after Wrongful Termination Following Complaints Unsafe Work Conditions

Dan Rather's Wrongful Termination Suit Against CBS is Dismissed Pursuant to "Pay or Play" Clause

Constructive Discharge Case At The Illinois Human Rights Commission

Sixth Circuit says local officials are liable for statements that cause discharge

Staffing Firm Settles Constructive Discharge Lawsuit For $20,000

California Court of Appeal Rejects Anti-SLAPP Motion in a Retaliation and Wrongful Termination Case

Community College Employee Allowed To Proceed With Wrongful Termination Claim Under The ADA In Blackburn v. Trustees

Clippers face wrongful termination lawsuit based on age, race discrimination in Los Angeles

Massachusetts Employers must pay Accrued but Unused Vacation at the time of Discharge

NLRB Upholds Discharge for Deliberate Betrayal, Despite Reliance on Unlawful Policy

Discharge Following Mistaken But Good Faith Wage Complaint Violates Public Policy

Court Permits “Public Policy” Constructive Discharge Claim Based on Sexual Harassment

Court Permits “Public Policy” Constructive Discharge Claim Based on Sexual Harassment

Employer's Pretextual Reasons For Discharge Warranted Liquidated Damages for FMLA Violation, Sixth Circuit Rules

Wrongful Termination and "At-Will" Employment in Kentucky and Indiana

6th Circuit: ERISA Remedy for Wrongful Denial of Benefits May Include Disgorgement Remedy Under Section 502(a)(3)

Keith Oberman sues Al Gore's Current TV for Wrongful Termination -- Olbermann Broadcasting Empire v. Current TV, LLC

6th Cir: ERISA Remedy for Wrongful Denial of Benefits May Include Disgorgement Remedy under Section 502(a)(3)

Massachusetts Wage Payment Act requires Payment of Earned Wages at the time of Discharge

Have an Employment Law question?

Virginia Employment Lawyers

Sheri Abrams Sheri Abrams
Sheri R. Abrams PLLC
Oakton, VA
Edward Lowry Edward Lowry
MichieHamlett
Charlottesville, VA
Matthew Sutter Matthew Sutter
Sutter & Terpak, PLLC
Annandale, VA
Gerald Lutkenhaus Gerald Lutkenhaus
Virginia Workers Compensation & Disability Lawyer
Richmond, VA

more Virginia Employment Lawyers